Is it time for us to crown Tom Brady as the Greatest QB ever? At this point in Brady’s career his resume can stand next to EVERY great QB, even Joe Montana. The consistency of excellence has lasted over 15 years. So, where does Tom Brady rank to you on the All Time QB list as well as the All Time NFL Player List? *** T-Hanes
Its hard for me to do cross generational because the game is not played the same when Mr. Montana played. Mr. Montana was the best during his generation and Mr. Brady is the best in his generation. I have come to the conclusion of not comparing after 10 year gap of play, you have to be in the same era. Now Mr. Brady to Mr. Manning, yes, Mr. Brady is to me better because Mr. Manning had the blueprint to how to play the game, while Mr. Brady had to come in the back door so to speak but became the best QB being drafted, what in the 4th round. While Mr. Manning was the first over all pick in the 98 draft. So we know the path of a first rounder to a forth rounder is night and day.
I never looked at it that way but I see your point. You really have to go by eras to be fair. The game is not played the same so its really not a way to truly compare. I will say that Brady is this generations Montana....meaning....the best
Agree 100%!!!